Pin It!

Butterfinger Brookies

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details

Three Butterfinger Brookie bars stacked on a mini white cake stand


We have this candy machine at work. It looks just like the ones at the grocery store, usually near the checkout stations. You put your quarter in and you get sticky bugs, a handful of candy or a temporary tattoo.

You guys know the ones I am talking about? The red vending-type machines that you bugged your mom for a quarter every time you went to the grocery store? So yea, we have one of those. Lately, the candy bar options have included bite sizes of butterfingers, and I have become totally hooked.

Two Butterfinger Brookie Bars with butterfinger pieces on parchment with a bite removed from one bar

Let’s talk about these Butterfinger Brookies, shall we? First of all, I am obsessed with brookies. I know I say I am obsessed with a lot of desserts, but seriously. A brownie on the bottom and a soft baked cookie on top? That’s better than peanut butter and jelly. I have a few versions now including a Oreo Marshmallow, a Cadbury version and a Thin Mint version as well. I also have classic brookie recipe!

A Butterfinger Brookie Bar with a bite removed sitting on top of a glass of milk with a straw

These Butterfinger Brookies really pack in the butterscotch flavor. The layer of cookies uses a butterscotch pudding in the cookie mix and is filled with butterscotch chips. The cookie layer sits on top of a gooey dark chocolate brownie that is lined with bite sized Butterfinger candy bars. There is no skimping on the candy bars either!

Butterfinger Brookie bars stacked next to a glass of milk

I am a candy hoarder, especially when candy goes on sale. Sometimes, I spend time browsing the candy aisle anticipating what desserts I could be making with all the different varieties of candy. It happens more than I am willing to admit. So recently I saw these “Butterfinger Bites”, which are about half the size of a mini candy bar. I thought they would be perfect for this recipe, as they were not too big or small. If you are unable to find this particular variety of Butterfingers, you can also buy the regular sized bars and just crush them up a bit.

Butterfinger Brookie bars stacked next to a glass of milk with a bite out of the top bar

So here is how I suggest to assemble these. Line your baking sheet with parchment paper or a baking mat (I prefer Silpat).  Make your brownie batter first and spread evenly on the bottom of the pan. Then take the Butterfinger Bites and line them up in rows, about .5” away from each other. One 10oz bag is more than enough to make this recipe. Then, make your cookie layer. Take the prepared dough and sort of flatten it in your hands before patting into the brownie layer. This helps prevent any one area from being too thick. You have to allow these to cool for a couple hours before you try removing them from the pan. It is a very heavy bar and will easily crack!

Try these Butterfinger Brookies for your next springtime get together with family or friends. They won’t disappoint!


Butterfinger Brookies

  • Prep Time: 20 minutes
  • Cook Time: 23 minutes
  • Total Time: 43 minutes
  • Yield: 16 bars


  • 1 Box Brownie mix
  • 1 Large egg
  • 1/4 C Milk
  • 1/3 C Oil
  • 1 pk Butterfinger bites (10oz)

For the cookie dough

  • 1/2 C (1 stick) Unsalted butter
  • 1/2 C Sugar
  • 1/2 C Brown sugar
  • 1 Large egg
  • 2 tbsp Pure vanilla extract
  • 1 3/4 C All-purpose flour
  • 1/4 C Butterscotch Instant pudding mix (3.4 oz pkg)
  • 1/4 tsp Salt
  • 1/2 tsp Baking soda
  • 3/4 C Butterscotch chips


  1. Preheat oven to 350° F.
  2. In a medium sized bowl, combine brownie mix, egg, vegetable oil and milk. Beat until thoroughly mixed.
  3. Line a 9×13” pan with parchment paper or a baking mat. Pour brownie mixture over the baking mat and spread evenly.
  4. Line the brownie layer with Butterfinger bites, about .5” away from each other.
  5. Prepare the cookie layer. Soften butter in the microwave 10-15 seconds. Combine butter with both light brown sugar and granulated sugar. Mix until smooth and mixture becomes fluffy.
  6. Add egg and vanilla extract and beat until egg is thoroughly incorporated.
  7. In a separate bowl, combine flour, butterscotch pudding, salt and baking soda. Slowly add flour mixture to dough batter while mixing at a low speed. Once all the flour has been added, increase speed to medium until dough forms. Add butterscotch chips and fold into cookie dough.
  8. Take the cookie dough and drop chunks onto the top of the brownie mixture, gently pressing them down into brownie batter.
  9. Bake for 23-25 minutes at 350°F. Remove from oven and allow to cool completely before cutting. Since I used a baking mat, I was able to completely remove the sheet of brookies from the pan before cutting.

Leave a Comment

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

19 Responses
  1. Diane

    Does the butterscotch pudding need to be instant? It didn’t specify and my store only had cook & serve or instant sugar-free.

    1. Julianne - Beyond Frosting
      Beyond Frosting

      Hi Diane. Sorry! Thanks for the head’s up! I will fix the recipe! You should use instant. That’s funny, I have been looking for Butterscotch pudding at a few different places and I too have a hard time finding regular butterscotch pudding too. So weird.

  2. Mara Aditajs

    My absolute FAV candy bar ever … BUTTERFINGERS!!! So this is “must make” recipe! I do have a question before I attempt to bake, in the instructions you say to add both sugars – but you do not list light brown sugar or how much in the ingredient list. Am I missing it?

    I had never heard of “brookies” until last month when my granddaughter asked for them for her birthday party in her Kindergarden class.

    Thanks, Mara

      1. Mara Aditajs

        Thanks for the quick reply!
        I will be making them for our potluck lunch at my Cactus & Succulent Show this weekend. I’m sure there won’t be any to take home!

  3. Lindsay @ Life, Love and Sugar

    Yum! I love butterfingers and have been wanting to try brookies. These look awesome! Pinned!

    1. Julianne - Beyond Frosting
      Beyond Frosting

      Thanks Lindsay! you HAVE to try brookies! It will be difficult to choose between brownies and cookies moving forward though 🙂

Subscribe to my newsletter and get my fav tips to take your cakes & cupcakes to the next level.