Butterfinger Pudding Pops

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details

Butterfinger Pudding Pops | beyondfrosting.com

Let’s talk about these Butterfinger Pudding Pops. I have come to really like Butterfingers. They are one of the most unique candy bars and it’s hard to find anything like it. All of the sudden this summer, I started buying them and using them in various recipes.

Butterfinger Pudding Pops | beyondfrosting.com

I made these popsicles a couple times until I was satisfied with the recipe. Too much pudding mix will cause these popsicles not too freeze all the way, but I am not sure why. They are super easy to throw together. It’s just a jar of Sweetened Condensed Milk, Cool Whip and some Butterfinger candy bars mixed with a little but of Instant Butterscotch pudding.

Butterfinger Pudding Pops | beyondfrosting.com

You do not need to mix the pudding with any milk, you just add the dry mix to the ice cream batter. It’s just amps but the butterscotch flavor in these popsicles. I made these popsicles using paper cups as the molds because that is what I had handy. I like the paper cups because when you are ready to eat them, you just peel it off the popsicles. If you love Butterfingers, these popsicles are for you!

Butterfinger Pudding Pops | beyondfrosting.com

Follow Beyond Frosting

Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Instagram


Butterfinger Pudding Pops

  • Prep Time: 10 minutes
  • Total Time: 10 minutes


An ice cream popsicle full of Butterfinger flavor.


  • 12 Butterfinger (fun size)
  • 1 Jar (14oz) Sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 tbsp Instant butterscotch pudding mix (dry)
  • 1 Container (8oz) Cool Whip


  1. Use a food processor to grind up the Butterfingers into crumbs.
  2. Combine sweetened condensed milk with butterscotch pudding and Butterfinger crumbs. Reserve 3 tbsp of Butterfinger crumbs to sprinkle on top of the popsicles. Beat until smooth.
  3. Add Cool Whip and beat until well combined.
  4. Divide batter between popsicles molds. Sprinkle remaining Butterfinger crumbs on top of the popsicles.
  5. Put a popsicle stick or straw in the middle of the popsicles and freeze for 6-8 hours.


Total time including freezing the popsicles.

Recipe Card powered byTasty Recipes

Recipes from my friends:

Butterfinger Pie from Recipe Girl

Butterfinger Ice Cream Cake from Java Cupcakes

Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie from Inside Bru Crew Life

Other recipes from Beyond Frosting

Butterfinger Icebox Cake

Buterfinger Brookies

Funfetti Oreo Ice Cream Pops

Oatmeal Pie Ice Cream Pie

10 Responses
  1. Julie @ Julie's Eats & Treats

    Ooooo Butterfingers! Talking straight to my heart girl! These look amazing. Have a great weekend 🙂

  2. Heather

    Wow! Those look so tasty! I, too, love Butterfingers. I seem to be the only one I know. I may just have to make these for myself 🙂

  3. Lindsey @ American Heritage Cooking

    I love butterfingers too! These pops look scrumptious and just what I need to beat the heat down here! Is it Fall yet? I just can’t get over how easy these are. Insane!

  4. Mir

    It’s a good thing you like your bro’s girlfriend! I’m sure she loves having you feed her, too!
    Love Butterfingers, and these pops are fantastic, with the varying textures of the candy bar and smoother base!

  5. Taylor @ Food Faith Fitness

    You can DEFS not have too many vacations! Sounds like you’ve got a fun weekend.
    And you know what else is SUPA fun? These pops! Pudding is a big deal in our house, and adding Butterfinger does not hurt! LOVE. Pinned!

Share a Comment

Subscribe to my newsletter and get my fav tips to take your cakes & cupcakes to the next level.
Skip to content