Moist Vanilla Layer Cake

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details

This Moist Vanilla Layer Cake is an easy oil-based vanilla cake recipe that is SUPER moist and spongy, you’ll know it’s a homemade vanilla cake. It’s decorated with the perfect vanilla frosting recipe.


A slice of a three layer vanilla cake on a white cake plate. The cake is decorated with shades of blue and teal frosting

If you’re just stopping by here for the first time, I want to be sure that you know that there’s a couple different versions of this cake. Each recipe is prepared with the same ingredients but tailored specifically for either cakes or vanilla cupcakes.

When I initially posted my Moist Vanilla Cake recipe, I got a lot of questions about baking it as a layer cake. The quick answer is yes, but it’s a little more complicated for a layer cakes, so I thought it deserves its own specific post!

The vanilla cake recipe is SO easy. It’s an oil-based cake recipe, so there’s no waiting around for the butter to soften or creaming the butter and sugar together. The oil also creates a more tender crumb in the cake. It’s gotten RAVE reviews.

This cake recipe is denser than it is light and airy, but it’s super moist. The cake is very sturdy which makes it a great recipe for layer cakes.

A gorgeous cake decorated with gold and teal sprinkles, and teal and blue frosting. The cake is sitting on a white scallop edged cake stand

The vanilla cake can also easily be altered for different flavors as well. This recipe is the same one I used for my Strawberry Mascarpone Layer Cake and this Blueberry Lemon Mascarpone Cake.

Tips for making this vanilla Layer Cake

This recipe makes three 8-inch layers. My 8-inch baking pans are go-to size. I line all my pans with parchment paper circles or a Silpat liner. I also generously grease the sides of the pan with Crisco and a light dusting of flour.

Finally, I use bake even stripes whenever I am baking round cakes. The bake even stripes help prevent the dome from forming on the top of the cake, because it prevents the edges from baking too quickly. As the edges of the cake bake, it pushes the batter towards the center, creating the dome.

You need nice, flat top cakes when you’re making a layer cake. If your cake has a dome, use a large serrated knife or a cake level to cut the dome off the top.

A tall slice of cake on a white plate. The cake is frosting with vanilla frosting

For this vanilla cake you’ll need quite a bit of frosting. Besides the filling in between the layers, you’ll need extra frosting for decorating. A batch of my perfect vanilla frosting should do the trick. If you don’t prefer the taste of American buttercream, you could certainly also make a large batch of Swiss Meringue Buttercream. 

A slice of a three layer vanilla cake on a white cake plate. The slice of cake has a few bites taken out of it

The BEST part about that frosting recipe is that it starts with COLD butter. It helps the butter from getting too soft when decorating or when coloring the frosting. Plus, there’s no waiting around for your butter to soften.

The one catch is that you have to beat the frosting for quite a bit of time, but this produces the best whipped, silky texture.

You want to be sure the frosting is not too stiff, or it will be more difficult to actually frost the cake. If you think the frosting is too stiff, you can add additional heavy whipping cream (or milk), 1 tablespoon at a time, and beat for a few more minutes.

Since this recipe requires so much butter, you might consider making only a half batch at a time if you’re using a standard 5-quart mixer. I have both a 5 and a 6-quart mixer, and I use my 6-quart mixer when I’m making this frosting. It’s a much larger capacity.

A close up show of a slice of vanilla cake on a white plate

Making buttercream and decorating cakes can be intimidating. I am right there with you! Thankfully, I have spent a lot of time writing about how to make buttercream frosting, so that you’ll be successful the first time around!

I love this Vanilla Layer Cake because I totally pushed myself out of my comfort zone in terms of decorating. I am NOT a cake decorator. However, after I took the Wilton Decorating course, it really helped me with the basics of how to decorate cupcakes and cakes. Of course, I’ve had a lot of practice over the years, but when it comes to cakes, I so often tend to stick with my go-to large open star tip.

However, for this vanilla layer cake, I wanted to do something different! I know most cake decorators would probably cringe at my uneven distribution, I mean I didn’t intend to decorate half the cake, but I think it’s darn pretty anyway.

A close up shot of a slice of vanilla cake with vanilla frosting

How to decorate this Moist Vanilla Layer cake

This is a super approachable way to decorate a cake. I never thought I was very good at piping roses, but you guys, it’s SO SO easy!

I just used a 1M piping tip. If you’re not fully comfortable, try piping a few of them on some clean parchment paper, and then you can reuse the frosting.

The other piping tips I used for this cake were a size 18 tip and size 21 open star tip. If you use your piping bags with couplers, you can easily switch out the tips. These piping tips can be purchased at stores like Michael’s or a cake supply store, or online. All of the small flowers and rosettes were made using a combination of these tips.

To color the frosting, you can use either the Wilton Color Right Food Gels or AmeriColor Gels. I think the AmeriColor gels because they offer a wide variety of colors and you can purchase them as single either online or at a cake supply store.

An overhead close up shot of a cake on a white cake plate. The cake is decorated with teal colored roses, blue rosettes and sprinkles.

The best way to dye your frosting if you’re looking for different shades is to start with a half a drop in one bowl and then get progressively darker. Just remember that you only need a TINY bit of this gel, to color these small amounts of frosting. It’s helpful to use a toothpick to add small amounts to your bowls at a time.

Remember to save some of your white frosting to decorate with as well. You need about 1 cup of frosting for the roses, ½ cup for the darker blue color and ¼ cup of the white frosting. Start by piping your roses, and then fill in the open spaces with the stars and rosettes.

I don’t want you to be intimated by making layer cakes. There is much more time and patience involved, but I believe everyone can do it, especially if you have the right tools. I am always here to answer your questions as well!

An overhead shot of a cake on a white cake plate. The cake is decorated with teal colored roses, blue rosettes and sprinkles.

Commonly Asked Questions:

Do I have to use Sour Cream cream?

As I mentioned above, sour cream helps keeps these cupcakes very moist. I recommend substituting the sour cream with non-fat Greek Yogurt if you do not have sour cream. Some people have made it with mayonnaise but I have not tried it myself.

If you only have full fat sour cream that will work, your cake might just be a little more dense.

A few people have asked about substituting buttermilk for sour cream. I have never tried this, and this batter is already pretty thin, so I am not sure if adding additional liquid will work.

If you need to, you can omit it completely, but note the cake will not be nearly as moist.

What other pan sizes can I use? Can I bake this in two 9-inch pans?

This recipe has been used for several other size pans without adapting the cake recipe- you just may need to scale the frosting recipe accordingly. 

For two 9-inch cakes, they baked from 28-32 minutes. Baking times will vary due to how full the pans are, type of pans and true oven temperature. Please note these did “crust” a little more on the outside edge due to extended baking times and they rose quite a bite in the middle, so you’ll lose more of the “dome” of the cake.

For two 8-inch pans: divide the batter evenly, about 2 1/2 cups per each pan. Bake for 28-32 minutes. 

For 6-inch pans: a full recipe will make four 6-inch layers, filling each one with about 1 1/3 cup of batter and baking for approximately 24-30 minutes. 

For 10 inch pans: I’ve never tested this with 10 inch pans, but I would recommend a 2 layer cake so you still have nice, thick layers. Trying baking for 18-20 minutes and assessing additional time needed from there. 

A large 3 layer vanilla cake on a white cake stand with a couple pieces missing

Do I have to use nonfat milk or can I substitute it with something else?

Yes, you can use any type of milk for this recipe.

I had to bake my recipe for longer than the required time, what did I do wrong?

Likely nothing! Different types of pans will bake differently. Glass baking pans will always need to bake longer as they do not conduct heat as quickly as metal pans. Disposable containers are much thinner and thus require additional baking time. Also keep in mind that not all oven temperatures are alike, and unless you have an internal thermometer, your oven temperature could be off.

Happy baking friends. Follow Beyond Frosting:

Facebook | Twitter | Pinterest | Instagram | Bloglovin 

If you love no-bake recipes, be sure to check out my cookbook, No-Bake Treats!



A gorgeous cake decorated with gold and teal sprinkles, and teal and blue frosting. The cake is sitting on a white scallop edged cake stand

Moist Vanilla Layer Cake

  • Author: Beyond Frosting
  • Prep Time: 90 minutes
  • Cook Time: 30 minutes
  • Total Time: 2 hours
  • Yield: 10-12 slices


This Moist Vanilla Layer Cake is an easy oil-based vanilla cake recipe that is SUPER moist and spongy, you’ll know it’s a homemade vanilla cake. It’s decorated with the perfect vanilla frosting recipe.


For the cake:

  • 2 cups (380g) granulated sugar
  • ½ cup (118 ml) vegetable oil
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1 tablespoon (14.8 ml) pure vanilla extract
  • ½ cup (118 ml) light sour cream
  • 2 ½ cups (350 g) all-purpose flour
  • 3 teaspoons (11.2 g) baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon (5 g) salt
  • 1 ¼ cups (296 ml) milk (I use nonfat)

For the frosting:

  •  2 cups (453g) unsalted butter, cold
  • 78 cups (910-1041g) powdered sugar
  • 1 tablespoon (15ml) vanilla extract
  • 23 tablespoons (30-44ml) heavy whipping cream (or milk)
  • Pinch of salt


  1. For the cake: Preheat the oven to 350°F. Prepare 3 8-inch round baking pans, line the bottom with parchment paper and grease the sides. Prepare your bake even strips if desired.
  2. In a large mixing bowl, combine the sugar, vegetable oil, eggs and vanilla extract. Beat on medium speed until the eggs and oil are well incorporated and the batter is lighter in color, about 2 minutes. Scrape down the bowl as needed.
  3. Next mix in the sour cream and beat until well combined.
  4. Combine the dry ingredients in a separate bowl. Add half the dry ingredients, beat on low speed while pouring in half of the milk. Mix just until the flour starts to incorporate.
  5. Finally add the remaining dry ingredients, mixing on low speed while pouring in the remaining milk and beating until all of the ingredients are well combined. Use a spatula to scrape down the sides of the bowl and stir the batter from the bottom to the top to ensure it’s well mixed.
  6. Divide the batter evenly between the three pan, about 1 2/3 cups of batter per pan. Bake at 350°F for 20-23 minutes. Rotate your pans in the oven halfway through baking.
  7. Test the cake for doneness by inserting a toothpick into the center of the cake. If the toothpick comes out clean, you cake is done. Remove from the oven and allow to cool completely.
  8. For the frosting: Cut butter into pieces. Using the paddle attachment, whip the butter for 5-7 minutes, scraping down the bowl occasionally. Beat until the butter looks light in color.
  9. Add 3 cups of powdered sugar and mix on low speed until incorporated into butter then add the vanilla extract and mix to combine. Beat for about 60 seconds.
  10. Next, add an additional 2 cups of powdered sugar and beat on low speed until sugar is incorporated. Increase speed to medium-high and beat for 3 minutes.
  11. Add the last 2 cup powdered sugar along with 2 tablespoons of heavy whipping cream. Beat on low speed until ingredients start to mix together. Increase speed to medium-high and beat for another 3-5 minutes to whip additional air into the frosting.
  12. To assemble the cake, use a cake leveler to cut the domes off the top of the cake. Place a dollop of frosting on your cake board and place the bottom layer of cake on top of that.
  13. Place about 2 cups of frosting in a large piping bag fitted with a large open round tip, or simply cut off the end of the piping bag. Pipe a layer of frosting on top of the cake, starting at the outside edge and working your way into the middle. Spread evenly with an offset spatula. Repeat with the second layer of cake and then place your third layer on top.
  14. Use your piping bag to fill in any gaps between your layers and to create a crumb coat. Using an offset spatula or icing smoother, wipe away the excess frosting, leaving you just enough to coat the outside of the cake. Do not mix your crumb coating frosting back into your icing if it has cake debris in it.
  15. Proceed to frost the top and sides of the cake using your offset spatula. Once the sides of the cake are covered, use you icing smoother to remove any excess frosting.
  16. To decorate this cake: Use your hands to press the sprinkles into the sides of the cake. It’s best to do this over a sheet pan lined with parchment paper, allowing you to easily capture and reuse the sprinkles that fall off the cake.
  17. Take your leftover frosting and separate into 3 bowls: 1 cup, ½ cup and ¼ cup of white frosting (undyed).  Dye the 2 bowls with you desired color. Remember you only need a touch of the gel color to dye your frosting.
  18. In a small piping bag, use a 1M piping tip to pipe the large roses on top of your cake.
  19. Place the other frosting in two small piping bags,  fitted with a coupler and size 18 or size 21 tips, fill with your other color and the white frosting. Fill in the negative space with a mix of stars and small rosettes.
  20. Keep this cake covered in an airtight cake container. Serve within 3 days for best results. High humidity and warm climates might consider keep this cake in the refrigerator and allowing the cake to come to room temperature before serving.


  • Depending on how much you fill the middle of your cake, you might need another half or quarter recipe of frosting to do your decorations, especially if you’d like to do more of a traditionally decorated cake with rosettes or something on top.  
  • Baking pans:
    • For two 9-inch cakes, they baked from 28-32 minutes. Baking times will vary due to how full the pans are, type of pans and true oven temperature. Please note these did “crust” a little more on the outside edge due to extended baking times and they rose quite a bite in the middle, so you’ll lose more of the “dome” of the cake.
    • For two 8-inch pans: divide the batter evenly, about 2 1/2 cups per each pan. Bake for 28-32 minutes.
    • For 6-inch pans: a full recipe will make four 6-inch layers, filling each one with about 1 1/3 cup of batter and baking for approximately 24-30 minutes.
    • For 10 inch pans: I’ve never tested this with 10 inch pans, but I would recommend a 2 layer cake so you still have nice, thick layers. Trying baking for 18-20 minutes and assessing additional time needed from there.
  • Sour cream substitute: Sour cream helps keeps these cupcakes very moist, I do not recommend omitting it. Substitute with with non-fat Greek Yogurt if you do not have sour cream. Full-fat sour cream is also workable, but I prefer low-fat or fat-free.
  • Any type of milk can be used (full, reduced or low-fat)
  • I have tested substituting 1/2 cup melted butter in place of the oil. The cake still bakes just fine but I prefer the texture of the cake make with oil,
  • To make this as a single layer, please see my other vanilla cake recipe.
Nutrition Information:
1 slice
  • Category: Cake
  • Method: Baked
  • Cuisine: American

Keywords: Vanilla Cake, Vanilla Cake from Scratch, Easy Vanilla Cake Recipe, Birthday cake Recipe, Easy cake recipe with oil

Recipe Card powered byTasty Recipes

You might also like:

Moist Yellow Cake Recipe

A slice of yellow cake on a gold polka dot plate with chocolate frosting and sprinkles.

Moist Vanilla Cupcakes

A single vanilla cupcake in a teal polka dot liner topped with beautifully pipped vanilla buttercream and sprinkles

Strawberry Margarita Layer Cake 

A three layer tequila vanilla cake with a strawberry frosting. This cake is garnished with sliced strawberries and lines

Mimosa Layer Cake

Whether you’re celebrating the holidays or not, this Mimosa Cake will be a crowd pleaser. This cake is a moist champagne sponge cake with an orange Swiss meringue buttercream frosting. 

134 Responses
  1. Araliya

    This is the best vanilla layer cake I’ve ever made, and I’ve been a home-baker for many years. It is light, airy, but still so moist. I’ve experimented with many recipes but this is by far the best I’ve ever had. I filled is with homemade strawberry jam and topped it with whipped mascarpone and berries as a summer dessert, and it turned out gorgeous. Thanks so much for this incredible recipe! Can’t wait to try more.

  2. M

    Hi i will be making this tomorrow for an engagement party. Do you think I can substitute the the sour cream for full fat Greek yogurt?

  3. Jasmine


    This is my go to base cupcake recipe. I love it so much. Lol. I wanted to know how you’d think adding pulverized freeze dried strawberries to the batter would work to make it a strawberry cake? If you’d think it work, how much of the freeze dried strawberries would you suggest?

  4. Ruth Stevenson

    i made this for my child’s 5th birthday and there was a lot of tears and disappointment.
    the icing was very runny, so much so that i had to throw the first batch away and start from scratch. but even then i couldn’t rectify it.
    the cake was absolutely delicious but due to the butter cream i had to scratch the 2 tier cake idea and settle for cake pops instead.
    to top it off the icing was too runny even for cake pops. to put it simply, the problem lies in the buttercream.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Ruth- I am sorry to hear this did not work for you. Sounds like you did not correctly make the buttercream. I can assure you this buttercream should not be runny AT ALL. It’s quite the opposite. I am not sure if you started with warm or room temperature butter (as this recipe starts with cold butter) or if you added too much liquid. This is the same recipe as my perfect vanilla buttercream, which has hundreds of positive reviews.

      1. Sena

        Thank you. 😊 One last concern. Cake pans that I have here are circle (24cm) and square (26cm) in shape. Would it be fine if i divide the batter equally into halves? If not, what would be the ratio for the two pans? How long would it take until it’s done?

        Still, i want to layer it as one. I’ll just cut the square cake circle then frost it with your buttercream recipe. Thank you Julianne.

  5. Sena

    Hi Julianne! i have buttermilk powder. Can i use it instead of sour cream? I want to try your recipe for my daughter’s first month this coming Sunday.

  6. Sana

    I have successfully made this recipe with no fail and this is my go to recipe for my fondant covered Vanilla Cakes as the cake needs to be a little sturdy under Fondant. I love this recipe.
    I have a question though. recently with the same recipe my cakes are coming out with a denser center. I’m making sure that I dont overmix my flour into batter as that creates a denser crumb. Any suggestion on avoiding denser cake centers?


    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Sana, thank you so much for sharing. I am glad you love it! Have you made any changes to your ingredients? Are you weighing the dry ingredients? It’s hard to say what might be causing it especially if you’ve made it before and it has not happened. I also recommend rotating the pans in the oven halfway through baking to help maintain an even bake.

  7. Charlotte

    Hi, I love this recipe and the first time I made it was brilliant but all attempts since haven’t come out the same and I think this may be due to oven temperature. I was wandering what temperature you would bake this cake in a fan oven?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Charlotte- sorry I’m not familiar with fan or convection oven baking but I believe the temperature needs adjusting

  8. Wanda

    I made this cake last week and it was delicious! I used a strawberry filling with chantilly cream. It didn’t last a week 🙂. Thank you for sharing your recipes with us.
    Ps. I’m not an expert baking cakes, but you make them so easy to follow. And yes I have your book 😊

  9. Jonna

    My husband and I are going to try to make this for his Mother for Mother’s Day this Sunday! 🙂 I love the decorating you did, just beautiful and we want to try to re-create it, but what colors did you use? We have all the wilton colors and the closest I can find are royal blue and teal?

  10. Elle

    Hi, is it possible to bake this recipe as a loaf cake and how long and what temperature would it need? Thank you in advance.
    This is my go to vanilla cake recipe and is out of this world good which is why I am asking.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      For a 9×5″ load pan, I have not done it myself, so I sure it will bake fine, I’d probably go 2/3rd full and bake for around 30 minutes, check and add additional time as needed. Not sure the texture will be quite the same, but I am super interested to hear how this goes for you!

  11. Maureen

    Hi this looks delicious and I can’t wait to try it. I was wondering about making it for a friend who insists on almost zero sugar in cakes( sigh, it’s cake!!!) How can I reduce the sugar and it still comes out right?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Maureen- the recipe is best prepared at stated. Some people have reduced the granulated sugar in the cake to 1 1/2 cups instead of 2, but it changes the texture of the cake.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Jody- I have not actually but I think it should work, you just need to figure out how much batter or baking time per pan.

  12. Emma

    This is the best vanilla cake recipe I’ve ever tried! Super simple and everytime I make it everyone loves it. The cake stays super moist after days and is just the perfect amount of sweet!

  13. Jasmine F

    Hi, I just made my first successful from scratch cake using this recipe! Thank you so much for sharing, I also made my first buttercream frosting from your blog. You’re site is awesome.
    I was wondering if I could make this Keto friendly for my diabetic grandmother…
    Say I replaced sugar and flour with Splenda(lessee amount than sugar) and almond flour? Do you think that may work?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Jasmine, I LOVE to hear this!! This is amazing, congrats! Regarding the Keto friendly option, all I can say is that you would need to try it first. I don’t bake with either of those ingredients, so I am not as familiar with them. You could halve the cake recipe (using two eggs) and run a test batch. I know that Almond Flour is not a one to one replacement with all purpose flour

  14. Lynn Spratley

    I made this cake for my husband’s birthday. I was soooo delicious! My first layer cake– it was very moist and tasty!!

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Cake flour and all purpose flour are not inter changeable. The height of the cake varies by how much you fill it and torte it.

  15. Lou

    I love this recipe but I would like to make a 10inch layer cake about 5inch in height and a 6inch round similar in height – what’s the best way to use the recipe for this? Double the measurement and how long to cook?

  16. Shannara

    I used this recipe to make to make my daughter’s first birthday cake. It came out so perfect this will now be my go to recipe when I make a vanilla cake. It came out so good and the cake once decorated looked so professional, people could not believe that I made it

  17. Anju Narendra

    Thanks for the recipe. I checked out the layered cake recipe as well.
    I want to use this recipe in a layered quarter sheet cake.
    I was thinking of doubling the recipe and then baking it either in 3 separate 9×13 pans (I don’t have quarter sheet pans, just the regular pans) or in 2 pans (and make a two layer cake). What is your recommendation?
    Thanks, anju

  18. Jessica

    Any chance baking soda is missing from this recipe? I just made it and it didn’t rise at all. Went over the recipe again and I know I didn’t miss any ingredients and pretty sure I didn’t mis-measure either.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Jessica, nope, no baking soda needed. This cake isn’t expected to rise a lot, especially if you use bake even stripes. You want the top of the cake layers to be flat to assemble your cake. Usually I don’t have a lot of the dome to cut off the top. But if you cake was truly very very flat, it’s possible you overmixed or your baking powder is not good.

  19. Jessica

    I’m not sure what I did but the cake was a little bitter?? Did anyone else have this problem? I don’t know if I’m tasting the baking powder or the sour cream?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Jessica, that’s interesting. I would say it may have been an issue with your baking powder, or your flour not fully incorporating.

  20. Lauren Reid

    I’m about to make this recipe. Is it okay to use warm butter? I didn’t even put it into the fridge because I assumed I would need them warm!

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Do you mean for the frosting? If you start with room temperature butter, the frosting may not be as stiff. If the butter is truly warm than you will need more powered sugar to make it stiffer, or perhaps you’ll need to throw the finished frosting in the refrigerator.

  21. Sherry Stone

    Would it mess up the recipe if I added vanilla pudding to the mix? Also can this be used for cupcakes?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      So I have tried swapping out some pudding mix with flour and I wasn’t happy with the results. It still baked fine but I didn’t care for the texture.

  22. Auralia

    How would you go about using only egg whites instead of whole eggs in this recipe? I’m trying to make a Fourth of July cake and wanted the cake to be more white then have the yellow hue. I’ve used this recipe multiple times and love how moist it is. I don’t want to lose its texture by this substitution.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Auralia. I am so glad you liked this recipe. I have not tested an egg white only version unfortunately so I can’t provide you with a helpful answer.

  23. Shanelle Smith

    This was THE best cake ever!! I followed the recipe to the T. I was wondering if you ever tried cake flour instead of all-purpose ?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      AMAZING Shanelle!! I love that! I have not tried it with cake flour myself, you may need to adjust the leavening agents

  24. Marilee Cottrell

    I’m preparing to bake this for my daughter’s birthday this weekend. Do the eggs need to be room temperature?

      1. Marilee

        Made it last night. Get to try it tonight. ? It was easy to put together and the batter was delicious! Can’t wait to slice into it later!!

  25. Amelia E.

    For almost 2 years I’ve tried to find the perfect vanilla cake recipe. I finally found it! This is my go-to recipe. All of the others have either been super dense, dry, or too moist (almost oily) & lacked flavor. But this one is spongy & a little moist, it also has that great vanilla flavor! It is perfect, in my opinion. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!!

  26. Rebecca

    Hi there, Can you tell me how much should i increase the recipe by for a 6 inch 4 layer cake? I doubled the recipe for 9 inch 4 layer cake and it turned out absolutely amazing. I usually make tall cakes, so please let me know

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Rebecca, Sorry for the delay! How thick of layers are you looking for? If you see my 8 inch cakes are about 1 inch or so thick and 1 recipe makes 3 layers. So for 4 layers in a 6 inch cake, one batch would make something similar. I’d try 1.5x the recipe to see if that would work, but I think you’re going to need to do some testing until you find what you like

      1. maria

        would it be ok to double the recipe for a 4 layer, 8 inch cake or would that change the consistency since it will be thicker than 1 inch per layer? thank you!

        1. Beyond Frosting

          Hi Maria, I think that should be okay, but the baking times need to be adjusted. If you have bake even stripes, I would recommend trying those

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Raisa, yes that should work just fine. You will need to adjust the baking time accordingly and you’ll probably have leftover frosting.

  27. Nellie

    The cake was a good texture and nothing was really wrong with it. I thought it was a bit plain but maybe that’s just how vanilla cake is. I made two layers and have lots of frosting left over.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Nellie, thanks for sharing. Yes, if you’re only making a two layer cake, the frosting would need to be reduced. If you still have it, you can freeze it to use for a later time.

  28. Laisa

    I saw this recepi and decided to give it a try 🙂 I’m glad I did, moist,nice texture & flavor. ( I did soaked my cake a little bit w cake syrup) I always do 🙂 This recepi makes 6 full cups of batter. I used (3) 6″ round pan (2 cup of batter per pan) cooked for about 35 minutes.
    I wish I was able to share a picture of the cake I made using this recipe. It came out very nice!

  29. Katrina Guest

    This cake tastes amazing but i hard to double the amount of time it was in the oven for. 40 minutes it took in an 8″ round, in curious if you had a light or dark pan?

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Katrina, how many layers were you baking in the 8 inch pans. I bake all 3 layers at once, but 40 minutes sounds like a really long time, because there’s only about 1 2/3 cups of batter, so it’s not that thick. I use a light pan greased and floured

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Annie, I have not tried it myself. My only concerns is there is a lot of batter in this recipe, and that it might be too much for 2 9inch pans. Baking times will definitely need to be adjusted. However it’s on my list to test this out.

    2. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Annie- I tested this over the weekend. For two 9-inch cakes, they baked from 28-32 minutes. Baking times will vary due to how full the pans are, type of pans and true oven temperature. Please note these did “crust” a little more on the outside edge due to extended baking times and they rose quite a bite in the middle, so you’ll lose more of the “dome” of the cake. Enjoy!

  30. Jill

    I rarely leave comments but I felt I had to for this cake! It was so delicious! It was light, moist and just had amazing texture and flavor! The only change I made was to add the zest of one orange and instead of 1 1/4 cups of milk I added 1 cup of milk and 1/4 of fresh squeezed orange juice…it lasted about one day in our house! Thanks for a great recipe!

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Wow Jill!!! That sounds AMAZING!! I love the idea and thank you so much for leaving me a comment, I love reading them. There are lots of recipes on here that start with a similar mix you might enjoy!

  31. Rachael

    I would like to try this recipe and I have a stock pile of regular sour cream. Would this alter the recipe in a negative way or would I be able to use it? Same question for the milk, I typically have whole milk, would I be able to use this?

  32. PAULA

    Hi, just found your site and am curious about your vanilla cakes. I have made countless vanilla/white cakes searching for the one I love most. I would like to try your recipe. My question is: I like tall cakes. My cakes average almost 5″ tall (I usually make 6″ layers, but sometimes 8″). Could you let me know about how tall your recipes/layer cakes end up? Thank you.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Paula, I can’t say off the top of my head by maybe 6-7 inches depending on how much filling you put in. I make 8 inch layer cakes, so they are not super tall.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Patty, this recipe is made with All purpose flour. I have not tested with with cake flour. I am not sure what cake & pastry flour is.

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Cathy, I have not made in in 2 9 inch pans myself, if they are only 2 inches high, then you probably will have a lot of batter, with increased baking times and a dome in the middle.

  33. Meg

    This cake was a huge hit!! Thank you! I had to make a vanilla cake for my sister’s baby shower. I had experimented with a couple other vanilla recipes that claimed to be “moist, best…etc.” only to be disappointed. I ran out of time testing recipes and crossed my fingers this was a good recipe. And oh my! It is delicious. I also did the frosting recipe that is with it. It was the perfect amount of sweetness for this cake. I only used the 7 cups powdered sugar. I felt it was a bit too thick still, so I added a bit of milk after the heavy whipping cream. This thinned and smoothed it out for a perfect buttercream! Thank you for this recipe. It is my new go-to for vanilla cake! 🙂

  34. Meg

    How or will it change the cake if I use regular sour cream in place of light? I think I am going to try this cake. I will leave a review after we eat it! Thanks!

    1. Beyond Frosting

      Hi Meg, it should be fine with regular sour cream, just a little heavier. The full fat sour cream will likely make it a little more dense.

  35. Annie

    You won’t be disappointed!!! I’m new to making cakes and I’ve searched Pinterest and tried multiple Vanilla recipes and this one is the only keeper I’ve found!!! My customer was beyond happy and thanks to you I did my job. This cake is absolutely delicious.. I want to make one for myself. Haha. Thank you for ending my search, can’t wait to try more recipes of yours!!!

  36. Monica Yakamook

    Hi Julianne,
    I know that this recipe calls for 3 layers. Layered cakes are my favorites to make, but I have someone who wants a regular sheet cake. Would this work for a 13×9, or will I have extra?

  37. Beyond Frosting

    Oh my gosh Amanda, this just warms my heart. Thank you SO much. I do work full time and my job does take me abroad sometimes but not as often anymore. I spend all my free time working on my blog and it means so much to me to see this comment. Have a wonderful day!

  38. Amanda

    The things you do, Julianne, are just amazing. When you create things like this cake, I just shake my head and say, “Wow, that girl is really talented.” You could have used this cake at your wedding, and speaking of that, as I read through your wedding post, I could not believe the extent you went to in order to make it special, memorable, and something only your sense of style and your eye for creating beautiful things could achieve. You are gifted. I think I read in one of your previous posts that you worked abroad and I don’t know what specific career area you are in, but whatever it is, your coworkers/company are very lucky to have you. I have been impressed with all of your berry desserts last week (like that strawberry stained-glass-looking cake you made), but taken into consideration with all that you do–I am just astounded.

Share a Comment

Subscribe to my newsletter and get my fav tips to take your cakes & cupcakes to the next level.
Skip to content